The Br. John L. Gilchrist, CFC Alumni Scholarship was established by the Bergen Catholic Alumni Association in order to honor Br. Gilchrist for his long-service to the school as a former faculty member and to the Alumni Association as its past Moderator. It was awarded at the Commencement Exercises to the graduating senior who best typifies the Bergen Catholic man. In 2013 and thereafter, it was replaced with the Alumni Association Scholarship Award.